CORNELL NOTES for sources

TITLE: Kite Runner Breezes Along With Little Flair
AUTHOR: Geoff Pevere
YEAR PUBLISHED: 2008

Main Idea #1: The movie version of The Kite Runner was nothing compared to the book itself

Summary: Geoff Pevere received the Kite Runner as a gift in the book version after he had watched the movie. From word of mouth he was sure that the book would be better but he made this assumption before actually reading it himself. He called the movie “uneventful” but said he could just imagine the suspense in the book being stronger. He said a picture is worth a thousand words, so obviously the words must have been strong and worth it to write a movie out of it.


Quote: “Sometimes it pays to be reminded just how many pictures a well-chosen word is actually worth.”


Question: How can you say that the movie is worse then the book considering you have yet to read the book?



How will this source help you write your paper? Throughout the year, we have read book while watching movies and from watching the movies while reading, it gives us a completely different perspective of the book.



TITLE: Pulled by the past
AUTHOR: David Kipen
YEAR PUBLISHED: 2003

Main Idea #1: The novel has a great source of literature; even the title in itself is a metaphor.

Summary: David Kipen goes into detail about Khaled Hosseini’s use of literature in his novel. The entire story in itself is one metaphor. This metaphor is a kite fight because in these fights, fighters are doing all they can to take over the sky and to do this, they eliminate all their opponents. Kipen agrees with many others that The Kite Runner, without seeing the movie, provides images in your head that compare the situations in the book to live situations that we all might encounter. He says that It benefits the reader if they did not grow up in Afghanistan to read it because it shows us exactly what it was like.


Quote: “Behind the title of first novelist Khaled Hosseini's "The Kite Runner" lurks a metaphor so apt and evocative…”


Question: Could it possibly be to TOO challenging with all of the metaphors. Would the average student have a difficult time understanding all of the hidden meaning?



How will this source help you write your paper? In our school, the board is always looking to enhance our literature with difficult terms that are hard to comprehend. This book would provide a great source of literature for all students. Even though it would be challenging, it would benefit the students.



TITLE: An Afghan’s battle with the past
AUTHOR: Kenneth Champeon
YEAR PUBLISHED: 2007

Main Idea #1: The Kite Runner teaches history of Afghanistan

Summary: This article talks all about how the history of the novel makes it more enjoyable. Considering nine eleven is somewhat recent, we all have our strong views on Afghanistan. This article shows how Afghanistan is a struggling country and by giving us the feel of the environment, we not only learn more about the main characters, but also how they survive with their surroundings.

Quote: “Although the book can sometimes be melodramatic and garrulous, it provides an extraordinary perspective on the struggles of a country that, until that doleful September day, had been for too long ignored or misunderstood. And despite its grimmer episodes, the novel ends with a note of optimism about Afghanistan's future, an optimism that the whole world would prefer to see unspoiled.”

Question: From reading the first several chapters, it is difficult to understand exactly how their lives work. Can knowing more about Afghanistan customs make the book more challenging that its almost too challenging.


How will this source help you write your paper? It is important for books to teach us not only with their themes and enhance our reading comprehension, but to teach us about the history of our world. The Kite Runner does this efficiently because it shows a young boys battle against his country, Afghanistan.

socratic seminar notes

WHAT DID YOU THNK OF THE ENDING?
Nicole thought it was a great twist and surprising ending. She thought it was good
Brent agreed with her he said it also was great that it ha an epilogue and an afterwards which summed up everything well.
Mariana thought it was the best ending that we has so far because ewe had closure

DID YOU WANT TO KNOW WHAT WAS GOING ON WITH FRANK IN THE BASEMENT THE ENTIRE TIME?
Brent thinks that there should have been more information. He wanted Dave to go into the basement to give us an understanding of how he is and how he’s feeling.
They all agreed that it would have been better if they went down throughout the entire story because it would have made the middle of the book better but the ending would have been less of a surprise

DID MONTANA RELATE TO ANY OTHER BOOK?
Dan thought that Macbeth related to this book in the suspense ways.
Nicole thought that it related to The Catcher in the Rye because of the parents expectations
Bret also agreed with Nicole because he said David was also, like Torey, trying to find his place in society.

DO YOU THINK THAT THEM LEAVING WAS A GOOD CHOICE?
Lauren thinks it was the right choice because its time they move on and even thought they shouldn’t forget about the past, it shouldn’t have to haunt them

DOES DAVID TEACHING HISTORY HAVE ANY SIGNIFICACE IN THE STORY?
Nicole thinks that as time moves on, there are more changes and he wants to teach the children how it use to be with discrimination with Indians

BOOK REVIEW RESEARCH!--with bibliography and summary

BOOK REVIEW RESEARCH:
1. http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9504E0DF123FF930A3575BC0A9659C8B63&scp=1&sq=the%20kite%20runner%20book%20reviews&st=cse
Bibliography: Hower, Edward. "The Servant." Rev. of The Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini. New
York. The New York Times. Aug.-Sept. 2007. The New York Times. 6 May 2008
fullpage.html?res=9504E0DF123FF930A3575BC0A9659C8B63&scp=1&sq=the%20kite%20runner
%20book%20reviews&st=cse>.
Summary: In this review, found in the New York Times, it summarizes the book by giving a bland description of what the book is about. Within each description, Edward Hower tells what he thinks the main idea of the book is. He believe that the main theme and idea is that we get a “ vivid and engaging story that reminds us how long people have been struggling to triumph over the forces of violence.”

2. http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?index=4&did=1280165161&SrchMode=1&sid=3&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&TS=1210083692&clientId=33870
Bibliography: Memmott, Carol. "Book Buzz." Rev. of The Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini. USA.
31 May 2007. USA TODAY. ProQuest. Pascack Hills HS Lib., Montvale NJ. 6 May
2008 .
Summary: Within this review, it also gives a brief summary of the book and it gives the numbers on how the book sold. Carol Memmott seems to believe that most people thought that The Kite Runner had a slow start, but once the climax began, so did the readers attention.

3. http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?index=6&did=1274274791&SrchMode=1&sid=3&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&TS=1210083692&clientId=33870
Bibliography: Ciabattari, Jane. "Book Review." Rev. of The Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini.
Los Angles, California. 24 May 2007. USA TODAY. ProQuest. Pascack Hills HS
Lib., Montvale NJ. 6 May 2008 pqdweb?index=6&did=1274274791&SrchMode=1&sid=3&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309
&VName=PQD&TS=1210083692&clientId=33870>.
Summary: After reading The Kite Runner, Jane Ciabattari said that it would stay with her for her life because Hoseini’s storytelling is a gift. She loves the “sweep of historic upheavals narrated with the intimacy of family and village life.”

4. http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?index=9&did=764494681&SrchMode=1&sid=3&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&TS=1210083692&clientId=33870
Bibliography: Whyatt, Edward. "Wrenching Tale by an Afghan Immigrant Strikes a Chord." The New
York Times. Vers. pg, E.1. 15 Dec. 2004. The New York Times. 6 May 2008
pqdweb?index=9&did=764494681&SrchMode=1&sid=3&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&
VName=PQD&TS=1210083692&clientId=33870>.
Summary: This source not only says what the novel is about, but it also shows how Edward Whyatt believes how Hosseini got his ideas for The Kite Runner. Whyatt had nothing negative to say about this novel.
5. http://news.therecord.com/article/293605
Bibliography: Pevere, Geoff. "Kite Runner brezes along with little flair." news.therecord. 11 Jan. 2008. The Record. 6 May 2008 293605>.
Summary: This descriptive Review explains how Geof Pevere got convinced to read the book. He claims that the book is even better then the movie, but it wasn’t until the movie that he considered reading the book. He claimed that the movie did not do the book its justice because the book was truly phenomenal.

6. http://news.therecord.com/article/334925
Bibliography: Italie, Hitlel. "Penguin Groups enjoys run of paperback sensations." The Record. 10 Apr. 2008. The Record. 6 May 2008 334925>.
Summary: This review is about the Penguin’s opinion. They pointed out just a few books about what they thought were the best this year so far. Even though this book was more of a hit last year, they still think that The Kite Runner was a huge success.

SIBLING RIVALRY

It is normal for siblings to have constant, meaningless arguments that never seem to end, but the rivalry between Wes and Frank isn’t the typical arguing. Wes and Frank clearly have been compared to each other at so many occasions that Wes seems to not be affected anymore. In part one of Montana, Larry Watson shows the difference in the standards between each son. Frank is worshiped for being “ a great war hero” while Wes just ignores the entire thing. Usually, siblings will be happy for each other when they are recognized, but when it is the siblings father only recognizing one son constantly, hidden jealousy occurs. Wes pretends to ignore the entire situation when it is obvious that he feels neglected; Wes SHOULD feel this way. It isn’t normal for a father to noticeably favor one son over the other, and the fact that Wes has learned to ignore it and deal with it says too much. It says he is so used to the feeling of being less then Frank in his fathers eyes.


There are ways to deal with sibling rivalry that don’t make you weak but make you stronger as a sibling and as a person. Wes, from Montana 1948, doesn’t understand that these tactics do exist, so instead he discards them. One example of how he can start changing his behavior in these situations is using his jealousy as motivation (Henry, 2088). Siblings Olympia and Keishana had academic competition. Although Keishana was doing better in school, Olympia used her jealousy over that to try harder and excel more. Wes has an issue because when he should use his bad relationship with his brother as motivation, he uses it as a weakness. Wes doesn’t know how to handle his envy of his brother properly. Another way to deal with it is talk to his father. Instead of keeping it bottled up inside of him, he should express how he feels. Seeking adult guidance will “ help resolve a problem between bickering siblings… your parents were once your age and likely fought with their brothers and sisters... prepare to compromise if your parents get involved” (Henry, 2008). Although Wes is an adult and may think he can handle the situation on his own, talking to his father would only make his dad aware of how he feels. If Wes were to change how he reacts towards his sibling and deal with it in a more mature way, things would chance and the jealousy would possibly be resolved.


All siblings’ fight, but not all siblings handle the situations in similar manners. After doing this research and reading the first section of Montana 1948, it shows what Wes, from the book, is doing wrong and how to handle it better. It is so obvious that Frank is worshiped by their father at a completely different level then Wes; after doing the research it came clear that Wes should approach his father about the situation. His father might not realize how sever the issue is, but instead Wes just hides his feelings which is not the right way to go. Wes should explain how he feels and if not, he should use his jealousy as motivation. He is going about everything all wrong and his jealousy for his brother is only making him feel week. I understand now that how I fight with my siblings does not even compare to how Wes and Frank secretively despise each other. If I were to read these two paragraphs to Wes, I believe he would get the point that he’s competing with his brother in the wrong way; Wes should use his brother’s successes as a driving force to make his own successes.


TO HEAR MORE OPINIONS ABOUT SIBLING RIVALRY, MONTANA, AND HOW TO HANDLE SITUATIONS LIKE THIS, CHECK OUT THIS BLOG ,.

Annotated Bibliography practice

Sholar, Allison. "History of Montana." The early History of Montana. By Allison
Sholar. Ed. Greg Lynar. Montana: Great Neck Publishing, 1999. Rpt. of "The
Early History of Montana." Montana Issue Aug. 1999: Page 7. Ebsco. 2008.
MasterFILE premier. 29 Apr. 2008 detail?vid=4&hid=12&sid=acfa3818-f8b4-49cb-a43d-5704a6e7ceb2%40sessionmgr104>.
Written by Allison Sholar and edited by Greg Lynar from the Parkview
Baptist School in Louisiana use laws of science and stories being passed on
to perfectly describe what Old Montana was like. They say that old Montana
is what new Montana is based off of. The people living there, as said from
this article, have similar beliefs but technology has advanced their lives
a small amount. Published in the Montana issue in 1999, ancient, old, and
somewhat recent Montana was described giving its readers a good explanation
of people’s lives living in that area.

The Guilty Feeling

To perfectly define the word guilt (click here to see more definitions about guilt., it is the state of having committed an offense. Committing an offense might cause guilt, but the feeling of guilt is more then what you do, its how you feel about what you did. It is human nature to make mistakes. People mess up and all people have regrets; feeling guilty for these mistakes is what drives people to fix them.
As you all know, I have an obsession with the network drama, One Tree Hill. When I think of guilt, I think of a certain plot from the play. I can just as easily tell you about how Dan felt guilty after killing his brother. I can easily tell you that Lucas felt guilty about cheating on Brook with her best friend. What’s not that easy to describe is how Peyton feels about her mother’s death. She feels responsible. Peyton feels like it is her fault that her mother died. Peyton feels guilt every time she visits her mother’s grave, for she remembers how it happened.
Peyton didn’t commit an offence. She acted like a daughter would and being a mother, Peyton’s mom did all she could to get to her daughter in the fastest way possible. To do this, she passed a red light. This one-second in time is what took her mother’s life. When Peyton talks about her mom’s death, she says, “ I shouldn’t have rushed her. I should have just been patient.” Thankfully, it was not actually Peyton’s fault, but the tragic loss of her mom drove her to feel guilty about every wrongdoing, including rushing her to pick her up, that Peyton had ever done to her mother. A death has caused me to feel guilty too.
Just a few months ago, my uncle died. It was so sudden and so unexpected. During dinner with my parents, he literally just collapsed; it was a heart attack. He never had heart problems before and he was the LAST person I ever expected to die. A few days before that was Chanukah and as always, I received cash with a card saying Love you, Uncle Less, Aunt Sheryl and the rest of the family. It was so unlike me, but I never called to say thank you. I never took five minutes out of my life to call my uncle and just say thank you for the gift I love you too. Then, he died and I thought wow I can’t believe I never called him to say I love you one last time.
Feeling guilty about not calling him made me loose sleep. I lost the last opportunity I had to talk to him. Sleep issues is a common
problems (click here to see more about how people chance when they feel guilty. when a person feels guilty about something. For instance, Lady Macbeth in Shakespeare’s play, Macbeth, slept walked because she feels guilty about almost forcing Macbeth to murder the king. She didn’t actually force him, but she made Macbeth feel as though it was mandatory and there were no other options. Macbeth wouldn’t have actually murdered King Dunkin if Lady Macbeth didn’t make him; therefore, Lady Macbeth feels guilty because if not for her, the king would still be living.
As a conclusion, everyone feels guilty about different situations. When you feel guilty, it changes your life and how you look at things. It makes you appreciate more and feel what you didn’t feel before. Both Peyton, Lady Macbeth, I, and probably every human living has felt guilty at one point in their lives.

Feminism

Standards for women have changed as time has progressed. Women started with no power (click here to see more about women gaining power as time went on!),.but eventually gained respect. Are people like Paris Hilton and Lindsay Lohan responsible for the lack of respect women have been getting within the past two years? Can a few people set the reputation for how females act through out the world? Women in the old ages worked so hard to move up socially and politically, but recently it seems as though all those women worked so hard for nothing. Apparently, the standers for women have gotten lower because only those that make mistakes seem to stand out; the ones that make a positive difference are just lost in the crowd. There are other types of women too that show their power in a different way.
Some females try to make a huge point that women deserve respect and power. A perfect example of this is Lady Macbeth, but she does not show her power in a positive way. She is extremely secretive about what she wants and manipulates others into getting it for her. She tricked Macbeth into believing he was a coward when he first said he would not kill King Dunkin. Later, Lady Macbeth made him feel un-superior, causing him to alter his opinion and murder the king. Feminism is a term many use to describe female behavior, but for each woman, the behavior is different. Feminism can not be defined by Lady Macbeth, or Lindsay Lohan. It is a term that does not have a single definition.